Agreed. You did a great job. Plus, I just think that the note you've struck is perfect from the perspective of buzz generation. You note a couple of points of contention without really dwelling on the negative... that's important for the fringe market of roguelikes.
Speaking of which, I would like to do a Cataclysm review... I don't think I have the ability (temerity?) to really become a member of the contributing staff, but I could certainly do a one-off, and it's a marvelous up and coming effort. Is that something that would have a place here?